top of page

Sweet Pies



Our Pies

Our Pies

****When ordering for pick up PLEASE choose a date/time. Selecting ASAP will result in a pick up time 24 hours from time pie order is placed Thank you****




Mom's Favorite

Traditional coconut cream pie, you’ve got that creamy base with coconut inside and homemade whip cream with toasted coconut on top & a flaky crust

$30

Mom's Favorite


Key Lime

Graham cracker crust with a custard like texture and that straight out of Key West lime juice

$30

Key Lime


Chocolate Buttermilk

A rich buttery, chocolate, sugar pie that taste like a creamy browning, with a flaky crust

$30

Chocolate Buttermilk


Buttermilk

Traditional Buttermilk pie just like Grandma used to make!

$30

Buttermilk


Chocolate Truffle

Its got that delicious oreo crust a rich creamy chocolate ganache base pie, with whip cream and chocolate sprinkles on top

$30

Chocolate Truffle


Pecan Pie

Traditional Southern Pecan Pie served up in a flaky crust

$30

Pecan Pie


Banana Pudding

Graham crust with a layer of bananas and banana pudding base topped with whipped cream, vanilla wafers and caramel

$30

Banana Pudding


Eclair

French Vanilla Creamy base in a flaky crust topped with whip cream and chocolate sauce

$30

Eclair


Sopapilla Pie

Billowing layers of flaky crust filled with cream cheese & sugar then topped with melted butter, cinnamon & sugar! Yum!

$30

Sopapilla Pie


The Holiday

This layered pie has pumpkin, pecan, cheesecake, and caramel all delivered to your taste buds in a flaky crust.

$30

The Holiday


Eggnog Pie

Light and delicious pie -tastes just like a big glass of eggnog!

$30

Eggnog Pie


Hot Chocolate Pie

Graham Cracker crust filled with luscious chocolate filling then topped with a Cocoa Whip Cream, marshmallows, and chocolate

$30

Hot Chocolate Pie


Sugar Free Chocolate

The most delicious sugar free chocolate pie you will ever eat

$32

Sugar Free Chocolate


Sugar Free Coconut

The most delicious sugar free Coconut pie you will ever eat

$32

Sugar Free Coconut


Keto Coconut Cream

Whipped coconut cream cheese layer topped with a whip cream layer & toasted coconut served in a pecan/keto cookie crust 24 net carbs for the entire pie

$32

Keto Coconut Cream


Cheesecake Keto

Whipped vanilla bean cheesecake filling inside a pecan crust. 24 grams carbs

$32

Cheesecake Keto


Reece's Keto Pie

Peanut Butter and Chocolate mousse filling made with Swerve sweetener inside a pecan crust. 28 grams carbs per pie

$32

Reece's Keto Pie


Gluten Free Key Lime

Our classic recipe key lime in a gluten free crust ***Pie is Gluten Free Friendly. Life of Pie is not a certified Gluten Free Bakery. Pie is made with Gluten Free Friendly ingredients - no gluten added to pie***

$32

Gluten Free Key Lime


Vegan Chocolate

Gluten free, almond free, dairy free, vegan chocolate pie ***Pie is Gluten Free Friendly. Life of Pie is not a certified Gluten Free Bakery. Pie is made with Gluten Free Friendly ingredients - no gluten added to pie***

$34

Vegan Chocolate


The Baron

An award winning custard pie, The Baron is a honey pie with a hint of heat from the infamous Habanero pepper. Aka Honey Habanero Pie

$30

Hot
The Baron


The Pirate

A key lime pie with a small amount of heat and flavor from the Jalapeno pepper.

$30

Mild
The Pirate


The Ghost of Blueberry Hill

A blueberry custard pie featuring the smoky flavors and heat from the Bhut Jolokia (Ghost Pepper).

$30

Hot
The Ghost of Blueberry Hill

Hours
Rebecca Lane
Mon-Fri 10a-6p

Closed Sat & Sunday

Judge Ely 

Mon-Fri 11a-3p
Closed Sat & Sunday

bottom of page